COMFEE’ vs Instant Pot Pro vs Ninja Speedi: Which 8-Quart Multi-Cooker Wins in 2025?
Tested side-by-side for 6 weeks — plus my top $0.99 cookbooks to master each appliance.
If you’re choosing between the COMFEE’ 8-Qt, Instant Pot Pro 8-Qt, and Ninja Speedi, you’re facing a classic kitchen dilemma: budget, safety, or speed?
As the author of 27+ $0.99 multi-cooker cookbooks, I tested all three for 6 weeks—making yogurt, tamales, 3-part meals, and family stews.
• COMFEE’ 8-Qt ($79): Best for budget buyers who want 16 functions under $80.
• Instant Pot Pro 8-Qt ($140): Best for safety-focused families (stainless steel, sous vide, yogurt).
• Ninja Speedi ($420): Best for time-crunched cooks who want 15-minute 3-part meals with crispiness.
8-Quart Showdown: Key Differences
| Feature | COMFEE’ 8-Qt | Instant Pot Pro 8-Qt | Ninja Speedi |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price | $79.04 | $139.99 | $420.00 |
| Pot Material | Non-stick (PFAS likely) | Stainless steel (PFAS-free) | Non-stick (PFAS likely) |
| Key Strength | 16 presets, Amazon’s Choice | Sous vide, yogurt, safety | 15-min 3-part meals, Steam & Crisp |
| Dishwasher Safe | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes |
| Best For | Budget households | Health-conscious families | Busy professionals |
Side-by-Side: All Three 8-Quart Powerhouses
See design, capacity, and real cooking results:
How They Performed in My Kitchen
COMFEE’ 8-Qt Strengths
- ✅ “Works great and less expensive than Instant Pot” (real customer quote)
- ✅ Perfect for risotto, beans, rice—feeds 6–8 easily
- ✅ Amazon’s Choice = trusted by 1K+ buyers/month
Instant Pot Pro 8-Qt Strengths
- ✅ Stainless steel pot—no PFAS, handles acidic foods
- ✅ Sous vide & yogurt—unmatched versatility
- ✅ Quiet steam release—great for open-concept homes
Ninja Speedi Strengths
- ✅ 15-minute 3-part meals—chicken + rice + broccoli, all in one pot
- ✅ Steam & Crisp = crispy outside, juicy inside
- ✅ SmartSwitch toggles between modes seamlessly
Your Secret Weapon: The Right $0.99 Cookbook
Each appliance shines with the right guide:
📚 My Top Cookbooks for Each Appliance
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is the safest pressure cooker?
Instant Pot Pro—its stainless steel pot avoids PFAS found in non-stick coatings (COMFEE’, Ninja).
Which is fastest for weeknight dinner?
Ninja Speedi—its “Speedi Meals” function makes a full 3-part meal in 15–20 minutes.
Which is best for yogurt or sous vide?
Instant Pot Pro—only it offers true sous vide and reliable yogurt functions.
Can the COMFEE’ really replace an Instant Pot?
For basic pressure cooking, rice, and stews—yes. But not for sous vide, yogurt, or PFAS-free cooking.
Final Verdict: Choose Your Kitchen Philosophy
• Buy COMFEE’ + Stockpot Cookbook if you want maximum value under $80.
• Buy Instant Pot Pro + Bean & Grain Cookbook if you prioritize safety, health, and versatility.
• Buy Ninja Speedi + Speedi Cookbook if you need dinner on the table in 15 minutes.
P.S. Grab my Free 4-Week Meal Plan—includes recipes for all three appliances!